Back To Top


Choosing the Right Scuba Diving Certification: A Comparison Guide

If you’re eager to explore the underwater world through scuba diving, one of the crucial initial steps you’ll need to take is obtaining a scuba diving certification.

However, with several certification agencies and courses available it can be challenging to determine which one aligns best with your needs and preferences.

In this comprehensive guide where we delve deeper into the key factors to consider when choosing a scuba diving certification, comparing popular certification agencies and courses to help you make a well-informed decision.

Understanding Scuba Diving Certifications

Before delving into this comparison it’s essential to grasp the basics of scuba diving certifications. A scuba certification validates that you have received proper training and possess the necessary skills to dive safely within specified limits.

Different levels of certification exist, typically starting with entry-level certifications such as:

Open Water Diver (OWD)

Training Level: The Open Water Diver certification is the basic entry-level certification for recreational scuba divers.

Prerequisites: This course has few prerequisites making it accessible to all beginners with basic swimming skills (you need to be able to swim for 200 meters and float for 10 minutes, don’t worry it doesn’t have to be elegantly). With this and passing a basic medical questionnaire you are all set for the Open Water Diver course.

Training Content: The course covers fundamental scuba diving knowledge and skills, including dive planning, equipment use, underwater communication, buoyancy control and safety procedures.

Certification Limitations: Open Water Divers are certified to dive to a maximum depth of 18 meters (60 feet) in a buddy team or under the supervision of a certified dive professional.

Advanced Open Water Diver (AOWD)

Training Level: The Advanced Open Water Diver certification is designed to further develop and refine diving skills beyond the basic level. It is typically made up of 5 speciality dives, with the navigation and deep dive being mandatory and the other 3 choices that of the student.

Prerequisites: To enroll in the Advanced Open Water course divers must hold an Open Water Diver certification or equivalent.

Training Content: The course consists of various speciality dives, such as deep diving and navigation (mandatory) and then it can be customised based on the student’s preferences. Some typical specialities would be night diving,  peak performance buoyancy, underwater photography, drift diving, and more.

Certification Benefits: Advanced Open Water Divers have expanded diving capabilities and can dive to depths of up to 30 meters (100 feet).

Rescue Diver

Training Level: The Rescue Diver certification focuses on developing self-rescue and diver-assistance skills.

Prerequisites: Candidates must hold an Advanced Open Water Diver certification (or equivalent) and have completed 20 dives. They will also need to obtain a CPR and first aid certificate, your dive shop can also train you on this.

Training Content: The course covers accident prevention, emergency management, stress management and rescue techniques both on the surface and underwater.

Certification Benefits: Rescue Divers are trained to assist in dive emergencies, perform diver rescues, and manage challenging diving situations effectively.

Divemaster (DM)

Training Level: The Divemaster certification is the first level of professional diving training.

Prerequisites: Candidates must hold a Rescue Diver certification (or equivalent), have logged a minimum number of dives (usually over 50), and have completed CPR and first aid training within the past two years.

Training Content: The course focuses on leadership skills, dive supervision, dive theory, risk management and assisting with diver training.

Certification Benefits: Divemasters can lead certified divers on guided dives, assist instructors with training activities and supervise diving operations.

What are the key differences?

Scope of Training: Open Water Diver focuses on basic diving skills, Advanced Open Water Diver expands on specialized diving techniques, Rescue Diver emphasizes diver safety and emergency response and Divemaster prepares individuals for professional diving responsibilities.

Depth Limitations: Each certification level allows for progressively deeper diving depths.

Preparation for Professional Diving: The Divemaster certification is a prerequisite for higher-level professional certifications, such as Assistant Instructor or Open Water Scuba Instructor (OWSI).

Overall, each certification level represents a milestone in a diver’s training journey offering increased knowledge, skills and responsibilities within the recreational and professional diving communities. It’s essential for divers to continue learning and gaining experience to enhance their diving abilities and contribute to dive safety and enjoyment.

Several organizations issue these scuba diving certifications worldwide, each with slightly different approaches and curricula. Let’s explore some of the most recognized and respected certification agencies:

PADI (Professional Association of Diving Instructors):

PADI stands out as one of the largest and most well-known scuba diving certification agencies globally. They offer a comprehensive range of courses from beginner to professional levels, focusing on skill development, safety and environmental awareness. Here at Jaguar Divers we are PADI instructors amongst others. We can certify you for your PADI Open Water Course as part of our Standard Open Course option.

SDI/TDI (Scuba Diving International/Technical Diving International):

SDI focuses on recreational diving while TDI specialises in technical diving. TDI provide training in advanced diving techniques and equipment, catering to divers interested in exploring deeper or more challenging dive sites such as Caver and Cave. At Jaguar Divers we can also train you under the SDI/TDI system.

ACUC (American Canadian Underwater Certifications):

ACUC is a reputable certification agency that emphasises thorough training and practical skills development. They have a strong emphasis on diver safety and education, with courses designed to instil confidence and competence in divers. Here at Jaguar Divers we are also ACUC instructors and can certify you under their system, that would be our Premium Open Water Course.

SSI (Scuba Schools International):

SSI is known for its flexible training approach. They offer a comprehensive range of dive courses allowing students to learn at their own pace with online materials and interactive sessions.

In the end, each of these agencies adheres to similar core training standards outlined by the World Recreational Scuba Training Council (WRSTC) ensuring that certifications are recognized and respected globally.

Factors to Consider When Choosing

When deciding on a scuba diving certification, consider the following factors to ensure you select the right program and scuba shop for your diving goals and preferences:

Instructor Quality: this is really the most important factor when choosing where to do your scuba training.

The expertise and experience of instructors play a pivotal role in your learning experience.

Look for shops that prioritise skilled and certified instructors who can provide personalised guidance and support throughout your training.

Some of the questions you should ask your instructor candidates are:

  • How long have you been diving? How many logged dives do you have? You want instructors who have been diving for years and have thousands of dives under their belts.
  • How long have you been training? How many certifications have you issued? You should prioritise instructors who have been training for years and have certified many other students in your course level before you.
  • Is the practical training going to be done kneeling on the ocean or pool bottom or horizontally while being in neutral buoyancy? Anything that may happen underwater will need to be resolved while floating in neutral buoyancy, not kneeling. Therefore instructors who teach safety skills to students while on their knees should be avoided. You want to be trained while attempting neutral buoyancy at all times.
  • Am I guaranteed to get my card at the end of the course?  No, because no serious instructor will guarantee you a certification at the end of the course unless you have shown proficiency in all safety skills. But don’t worry with the right training and your willingness to learn this rarely happens.

Course Structure and Content: Review the curriculum of each agency’s courses. Are they comprehensive? Do they cover topics you’re specifically interested in, such as marine conservation or underwater photography? Look for courses that align with your interests and future aspirations in diving.

Cost and Accessibility: Compare course fees and availability in your area vs. your favourite tourist destinations. Enquire about any additional costs such as equipment rental or study materials.

If you live far from the ocean, bear in mind that you can do your theory and pool with a local dive shop and then finish your open water dives for the course in a tropical destination like Playa del Carmen 😊

Dive shops often offer packages for multiple courses, so it’s worth exploring all options before making a decision. Cheap and fast doesn’t make the best course.

Reputation: While most certification agencies are widely recognized opening you up opportunities for diving worldwide and ensuring that you meet the required skills and qualifications. Choose a shop with a good reputation and feedback from past students.  Good instructors, facilities and equipment.


In summary, choosing the right scuba diving certification is a pivotal decision that can significantly impact your diving journey.

Take the time to research various certification agencies, consider your learning preferences and seek recommendations from experienced divers or dive centres.

Whether you choose PADI, SDI, ACUC, SSI or others like NAUI or CMAS obtaining your scuba diving certification is the first step towards embarking on unforgettable underwater adventures and exploring the beauty of our oceans. Happy diving!

Instructor & Cave Guide